7 ridiculous trades we’d like to see in the 2025

Introduction

You might want to shout at the author for what follows — and that’s fair. This yearly column isn’t about making friends. It’s about imagining bold, borderline absurd trades that could flip the baseball world upside down. The focus is on fun, on the wild “what ifs” that could redefine the 2025–26 MLB offseason.

The Spirit of Hypothetical Trades

Every winter, fans dream up impossible scenarios that spark endless online debates. Some of these trade ideas aim to fix teams instantly, others simply aim to amuse. The reality is that many of these deals will never happen — but imagining them helps spotlight each franchise’s ambitions and weaknesses.

Seven Crazy Trade Ideas

1. The Angels Finally Trade Mike Trout

After years of speculation, the Angels could decide it’s time. A blockbuster swap that sends Trout to a contender for a package of top prospects could reset their roster while giving Trout one last real shot at a championship.

2. Juan Soto Lands in San Francisco

If the Yankees hesitate to extend Soto, the Giants might pounce. Adding Soto to a lineup already rich in young hitters could make San Francisco a powerhouse overnight.

3. The Brewers Go All-In on a Pitching Ace

Milwaukee might surprise the league by packaging several high-end prospects to acquire a top starter from a rebuilding team, signaling that the NL Central is theirs to lose.

4. Padres Swap Stars for Stability

The Padres could exchange one of their massive contracts — perhaps Fernando Tatis Jr. — for a combination of rotation depth and financial flexibility, reigniting the rebuild conversation in San Diego.

5. The Mets Trade for Shohei Ohtani

Imagine Ohtani in Queens — pitching and hitting under the brightest lights in baseball. It’s unlikely, but stranger things have happened in New York.

6. The Cubs and Red Sox Pull a Classic Swap

Both historical franchises could exchange underperforming stars to refresh their cores, much like their front offices have done in past decades when desperate times demanded bold moves.

7. The Dodgers Make an Absurd “Why Not?” Deal

Because the Dodgers always can. Maybe they chase another MVP-caliber player — just because they have the assets and the willingness to do it. These are the trades that make baseball rumors so entertaining.

Closing Thoughts

Quote:

"The point isn’t accuracy — it’s chaos."

That’s the energy behind every one of these proposals. Baseball thrives on the unexpected, and while most of these trades will stay hypothetical, they keep the offseason alive for fans hungry for drama.

Author’s summary: A playful exploration of wild MLB trade scenarios that spotlight team strategies, fan fantasies, and the unpredictable magic of the offseason.

MLB.com — 2025-11-28