49 Thoughts I Had While Watching Episode 1 of ‘All’s Fair’

The show feels like Ryan Murphy gathered an ensemble of legendary actresses, blended their energy together, and hit the creative “pulse.” I’ve always appreciated Murphy’s flair for the theatrical—his taste for the dramatic and surreal keeps things intriguing. It’s no surprise that his new star-filled legal drama, All’s Fair, instantly drew me in.

First Impressions

All’s Fair features a powerhouse cast that includes Glenn Close, Teyana Taylor, Naomi Watts, Sarah Paulson, Niecy Nash, and Kim Kardashian. With such a lineup, the series seemed destined to land firmly in the category of “guilty pleasure.” Still, I was curious to see whether it lived up to that promise.

The show feels like Ryan Murphy tossed a bunch of legendary actresses in a Vitamix and hit “pulse.”

Context and Style

Murphy’s productions often walk a fine line between stylish melodrama and cultural satire. This new project appears to continue that tradition, combining elegance, excess, and a cast that adds both prestige and chaos. Fans of Scream Queens and The Politician will likely feel right at home here.

Additional Recommendations

Vintage photos of a young Martha Stewart before she became a lifestyle icon.
28 cozy, autumnal films to watch this fall.
21 thoughts after watching the teaser for Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights.

Stay Updated

For more discussions on culture, politics, sports, and fashion, tune in to The Run-Through with Vogue podcast. Subscribers can access all Vogue content through the Vogue Runway app, which now includes new social features and curated posts from contributors.

Author’s summary: Ryan Murphy’s All’s Fair opens with extravagant flair, uniting a stellar cast in a stylish, over-the-top legal drama that demands attention.

Vogue — 2025-11-06